It is a commonplace that most novels are, in some way, autobiographical. The same may be said of readers and the novels they choose, relish, and identity with. I am re-reading Evelyn Waugh's novels of the Second World War: The Sword of Honour trilogy (Men at Arms, Officers and Gentleman, and Unconditional Surrender), and Put Out More Flags, a satire on vapid society youths and the early months of the war - known at the time as the "Bore War" (the term "Phoney War" was American in origin and only adopted later). Brideshead Revisited also trespasses into the War, more about which anon.The novels reflect Waugh's own experiences as an army officer, joining the Service in 1939 at the age of 36. Guy Crouchback, the protagonist of the Sword of Honor novels, is also this age at the outbreak of war - considered a sort of "middle age" at the time, meriting the fictional officer the nickname of "uncle" among his much younger fellow subalterns. Today it might just be considered the tail end of a very extended adolescence.
There are two opposing sides to Waugh's depiction of army life. On one hand he clearly and deftly satirizes his own experiences of army ineptitude - expressing loathing, the reality of daily monotony, inflexibility, and undue attention paid to the trivial and the outmoded. No one who has ever gone on any army exercise could fail to laugh at the descriptions of the manoeuvres, a classic example detailed in Chapters II and III of Put Out More Flags. The word most employed by Waugh is "shambles," and the shambolic is concisely expressed in the following: "Presently the order came back to march tactically. They knew all about that; it meant stumbling along in the ditch..." Indeed, Waugh's evocation of military life calls out across the ocean and 60 or more years. The similarities of experience outweigh the differences, and modern technology has done little to change the feelings evoked in Waugh's novels: the regimental system, the mess, the barracks and parade square, the mustering of the convoy, the chill of dark winter patrols, and the heat of the forced march in summer.
But there is another aspect to Waugh's writing on the army that hints at something deeper, something that permeates the feelings of his protagonists. For Waugh uses the army to express sorrow and love in a profound way - emotions his protagonists, for reasons of temperament, class, upbringing, religion, and otherwise, are unable to express in conventional ways. The sorrow of his characters is palpable and transcendent. Think of Charles Ryder, ill-at-ease in his Commission, arriving at the diminished wartime Brideshead. He is acutely aware of what he once was - the fortunate one who had "found the low door in the wall" at Oxford. He had, for a fleetingly brief period, discovered that other parallel life beyond mere humdrum existence and he is painfully aware that he will never recover it.
His "middle-aged" characters express this sorrow of thwarted existence so aptly through their army service. They know that their lives have not turned out as expected; they feel the shame of failure and irrelevance nipping at their heels. The grand strategies of nations, the tragedy of conflict, even the possibly of their own mortal demise, are distant concepts. The army brings them both out of themselves and makes them thoroughly aware of themselves.